My daughter now 6 years old had this shoes when she was 3 yo & loved it. We got two of them again, black, & white but now they are very wide. Almost both her feet can fit in one. I was very bummed about it.These shoes were bought for my 5 year old granddaughter to wear with her Wizard of Oz Dorothy costume for Halloween 2019. She is a girly-girl and has had other red sparkly slip-ons that she has grown out of. She wears these shoes with all of her dresses and pants that they match and she LOVES them! They are true to size, very well made, and comfortable. There were so many color choices that I was glad I knew what color I needed or I would have had a hard time deciding between them. Now I just want to buy her one of each color :)It’s hard to rate bc my daughter actually has kind of wide feet. But these shoes fit perfect but look a little loose. But my daughter loves them. I bought them in a size 10, which is her normal size - they look wide to me but she wears them for long periods of time and says they’re comfortable. They’re really cute too. So I guess I’d say they’re true to size but a but wider than normal, but still comfy?Bought as a Halloween shoe! Worked great and now used as a dress up shoe...Ordered these for my granddaughter to wear with her Christmas dress. They are adorable. Cute as can be. Well constructed and a great price. I may just have to order her another pair in another color.Adorable shoes, but they run at least a size big. They won't work for what I need them for right now, but I think they will fit perfectly around Christmas.My daughter loves these shoes. She wanted to be like Dorothy from The Wizard of Oz movie.. I wanted a shoe that wouldn’t fall apart super quick or was too slick on the bottom. This shoe has great grip. Very happy with my purchase. Would recommend for a more practical Dorothy shoe.